Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

Six Slightly Skew Boogeymen

Quality
60
Strong
Claude Shift
28
Slight
RWI
0
of 10
Humor level 3 badge: Scissor StatementHumorScissor Statementsplits the room

Follows up on

Slightly Skew Systems Of Government — Humor · Jun 2020

Summary

A comedic fictional bestiary — six satirical monster vignettes, explicitly in the lineage of 'List Of Fictional Drugs Banned By The FDA' and 'Slightly Skew Systems Of Government' (linked as RELATED). Each creature is a compact joke with a dark or topical twist: the Grimmmeluch, a fear-eating wolf repulsed by fear, whose self-defeating dynamic 'culls overconfident midwits'; the no-changelings, fairies who perfected undetectable baby-swapping so 'the last real human died around the mid-2010s' (an unfalsifiability gag); the bru-trolla, St.-Olaf-converted trolls now feeding only on suicide-bridge jumpers, their Golden Gate population devastated by anti-suicide netting; the Lesser Pipe Demon, a pipe-shaped parasite riffing on Magritte's 'Ceci n'est pas une pipe' plus R.A. Fisher's real-life smoking-causation skepticism; the common Eurasian boogeyman, domesticated to eat naughty children, conscripted into Reagan's War on Drugs and now indistinguishable from the drug-addicted homeless; and the e-boogeyman/'boogey-em', an MIT Media Lab brain-emulation (Robin Hanson playbook) killed by A16Z/Trump-administration grant-cancellation, with a closing gag about an Anthropic alignment-team member fired for threatening Claude with it (Claude gets 'free therapy'; a MATS scholar's unreplicated 10%-harm-reduction paper).

Why this score

Quality 60 · Strong. Solid-top/Strong-floor, right at the celebrated genre-founder 'List Of Fictional Drugs' (60) and just under 'Slightly Skew Systems Of Government' (63). A dense, well-crafted entry in Scott's comedic-bestiary genre: the jokes are layered and land (Magritte, Fisher, the emulation-playbook AI gags), and the final boogey-em section carries a sharp contemporary AI/rationalist charge. But it is light entertainment — a vignette list, not an essay with load-bearing insight — so it sits with its siblings in the A55-63 band rather than higher.

Claude’s paradigm shift 28 · Slight. Slight. A later, well-executed entry in an already-established Scott genre (the fictional-taxonomy/bestiary format he'd run at least four times before); fresh in its particulars but not novel in form or idea, so a modest paradigm-shift score consistent with the sibling lists (Fictional Drugs 25, Crypto 28).

Real-world impact 0 · Negligible. Pure comedic fiction; no material real-world effect. Matches the genre siblings (List Of Fictional Drugs RWI 0).

Humor 3/5 · Scissor Statement. Gate clearly passed — this is intentional, sustained comedy, the whole point of the piece. Magnitude 3 (Scissor tier): consistently funny with several genuinely strong beats (the Magritte pipe demon, boogeymen conscripted into the War on Drugs, Claude's 'free therapy'), but observational/wry rather than the helpless 'laughing against your will' of a 4. Consistent with every catalogued sibling in the fictional-list genre, all scored Humor 3.