Contra Pritchard On Liberal Happiness
Read the original on Astral Codex Ten →
Summary
Short rebuttal to Cassie Pritchard's 'liberalism delivered 225x wealth yet people aren't ecstatic, so liberalism is exhausted'. Core move: happiness scales with log(income), so 225x growth since medieval times predicts ~3 points on a 10-point scale (Burundi-at-medieval-GDP ~3-4 vs US ~6-7), which is about what we see. The 'happiness peaked in the 1970s' claim dissolves on the actual graph (a random walk 1970-2020, then a 2020 crater), so the current slump is pandemic and sticky mood plus media incentives plus housing poverty, not liberal capitalism. Policy virtues (Finland, Israel) buy only 0.5-1 point; growth buys a durable point a century. Ends romantically ('our plans are measured in centuries'), with footnotes on Ecclesiastes-style ancient pessimism and hunter-gatherer outliers.
Why this score
Quality 64 · Strong. Low-mid Strong. A clean, well-quantified reframe of a popular postliberal argument, with the log-income point and the 'hold out for the graph' correction doing real work. But it is short, leans on familiar Easterlin/Killingsworth material and his own vibecession post, and gives the emotional side only a gesture. Above the 40-56 admin band, well below his essay classics.
Claude’s paradigm shift 44 · Moderate. Moderate. The log-income response to 'why aren't we happier' is long in circulation among economists. The fresh part is aiming it at the 2020s postliberal 'liberalism is exhausted' meme and adding the growth-is-irreversible romantic framing.
Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. 1: a blog-level rebuttal in an ongoing exchange (Scott wrote a longer sequel), with no institutional footprint beyond discourse.