Legal Systems Very Different From Ours, Because I Just Made Them Up
Read the original on Slate Star Codex →
Summary
A humor/thought-experiment piece parodying Friedman's Legal Systems Very Different From Ours by inventing seven absurd-but-clever fictional systems: Clamzoria (sue rivers/wind/Death, collect from windmills), Pohjankaupunki (punishment via prodepressant rimonabant), Sloviria (punish Society via the social graph), Nova-Nishistan (a legal system based on blackmail + dead-man's-switch-as-a-service), Bogolia (mandated equal-priced counsel), Sanzorre (accidental anarcho-capitalism via malpractice/grievance insurance), and Mirakoth (no laws, random 7/49-judge panels). Each is a genuinely inventive mechanism-design thought experiment dressed as comedy.
Why this score
Quality 64 · Strong. 64 — low Strong. Cleverer than a throwaway comedy piece: each invented system is a legitimately interesting mechanism-design thought experiment (the blackmail-based and insurance-anarchocapitalism ones especially), and the execution is inventive and sustained. Held at low-Strong because it's a comedic exercise rather than a developed argument.
Claude’s paradigm shift 40 · Moderate. 40 — Moderate floor. A parody format (of Friedman) with clever individual ideas but a comedic exercise overall.
Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. 1 — negligible. A humor/fiction piece; no material reach.
Humor 3/5 · Scissor Statement. 3 — Scissor tier; gate passes clearly. A PRIMARILY-comedic thought-experiment-fiction piece — the invented absurd systems ARE the post, sustained and inventive across seven vignettes; magnitude 3 (clever-funny), below Moloch-4's helpless laughter.