Psychology Research Is Mostly Fine
Read the original on Astral Codex Ten →
Follow-up reading
↳ The Beauty Of Settled Science — reframing: settled science vs novel research · Aug 2026
Summary
Short corrective against treating the replication crisis as having discredited 'psychology'. Using the OpenStax intro textbook's table of contents, he shows social psychology is one chapter of sixteen and social priming a tiny sub-sub-field; most of psychology (psychophysics, psychopharmacology, psychometrics, personality, memory, neuropsychology) is fine. He then runs a long comic catalogue of who you are actually mocking: Jungians, Kegan-stage developmentalists, evo-psych listicles, 'whatever the heck Karl Friston is doing'. He concedes that hyped results anywhere fail (his own grantee's EEG-entrainment non-replication) and closes: if you don't like social priming, say so and leave the rest alone. Commenter pushback led to the reframing follow-up 'The Beauty Of Settled Science'.
Why this score
Quality 60 · Strong. Low Strong. A useful, correct deflation with a good concrete device (the textbook ToC), but brief and largely a matter of scope-policing. By Scott's own admission the framing was flawed (subfield vs settled science) and was fixed in the follow-up, which caps it.
Claude’s paradigm shift 34 · Slight. Slight-to-moderate. 'The replication crisis is concentrated in social psych' is a common insider observation; the contribution is putting it bluntly to a general audience.
Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. 1: blog-discourse corrective with no measurable footprint.
Humor 1/5 · Lizardman’s Constant. 1: clears the gate narrowly. The extended catalogue of psychologists (the Horney joke, the Jungians and 'the Divine Feminine', the 'Number Six Will Shock You' evo-psych gag, Friston) is a deliberate comic set-piece making up a meaningful share of a short post, not ambient wit. Still a minor element of a serious argument, so 1 rather than 2 (cf. the planted-gag precedent ACX-830).