Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

The Beauty Of Settled Science

Quality
64
Strong
Claude Shift
40
Moderate
RWI
1
of 10

Follows up on

↳ Psychology Research Is Mostly Fine — Essay · Jul 2026

Summary

Correction and reframe of 'Psychology Research Is Mostly Fine' after commenter pushback. The right line isn't social priming vs other subfields; it is novel research vs the deposit of settled science. He lists a dozen favorite settled findings (dopamine prediction error, 5-HT2A and psychedelics, cortical localization and plasticity, ~50% heritability with little shared environment, gamma and consciousness, GABA-A subunits, memory systems, the real-but-limited efficacy of treatments, schizophrenia genetics, reinforcement schedules) and quotes Yudkowsky's 2008 'The Beauty Of Settled Science'. Social priming was a disaster precisely because it crept toward settled status before collapsing. He then addresses commenters whose psychology is only bad DEI-driving studies, splitting them into the bad-heuristics camp ('your heuristics aren't that bad') and the propaganda camp ('a confession, not an excuse'), and footnotes the education-research counter-case.

Why this score

Quality 64 · Strong. Low-mid Strong. Better than its parent: the settled-vs-frontier distinction is the right one and is illustrated with a genuinely informative list, and the response to the 'discredit psychology for political reasons' move is crisp. Still a short follow-up whose central idea is explicitly borrowed from Yudkowsky.

Claude’s paradigm shift 40 · Moderate. Slight-to-moderate. Restates the 2008 Yudkowsky point, applied to the post-replication-crisis 'psychology is fake' discourse.

Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. 1: blog-level corrective.